Most bid/no-bid decisions are made in a short meeting, on a hunch and a spreadsheet with one cost number. Then the price is set by taking that number and adding the usual margin. Both steps leave money on the table: you chase tenders you were never likely to win, and you price the ones you do chase without knowing your chance of winning or of losing money.
A good bid decision answers two questions in order. First: is this tender worth our bid cost and our best people? Second: if it is, which price gives the best balance between winning and earning? This guide covers a simple scorecard for the first question and a risk-based way to answer the second.
Why gut-feel bid/no-bid fails
Bidding on large infrastructure and energy tenders is expensive. Design, estimating and legal work can run into the millions, and the same team can't work on two big bids at once. Yet the go decision is often driven by things that don't predict success:
- Order book pressure. When the pipeline looks thin, every tender looks attractive.
- Optimism about the win chance. Teams rarely know their real hit rate, so they assume a good one.
- One cost number. Without a range, nobody can see how likely a loss is at a given price.
- Sunk cost. Once pre-qualification work is done, walking away feels like a waste, even when the case has weakened.
The result is a low hit rate, a bid team stretched thin, and contracts won at prices that turn out too low. A structured decision doesn't remove judgment. It makes the judgment visible, so the bid board can challenge it.
A simple bid/no-bid scorecard
Score each criterion from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong) and agree the weights once, not per tender. The weights below are an example. What matters is that you use the same scorecard every time, so tenders can be compared.
| Criterion | Question | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Strategic fit | Does this client, region and type of work fit where we want to grow? | 20% |
| Win chance | How many bidders, how strong, and do we have an edge on price or quality? | 25% |
| Capacity | Do we have the bid team now, and the delivery team when the contract starts? | 15% |
| Risk | Are the contract terms, ground conditions and interfaces risks we can price and control? | 20% |
| Margin | Can a price that wins still earn our minimum margin? | 20% |
Add a few knock-out questions that override the score: unlimited liability you can't insure, a missing key qualification, or a bid cost out of proportion to the expected return. If any of them is a hard no, the answer is no-bid, whatever the total.
Two of the five criteria, win chance and margin, are really one question seen from two sides. A higher price raises the margin and lowers the chance of winning. That's where pricing under risk comes in.
Pricing a tender: win probability against margin
Each possible bid price gives you two things: a probability of winning, and a profit if you win. Neither alone tells you what the price is worth. The figure that combines them is expected profit:
Expected profit = P(win) × profit if won − bid cost
A low price wins often but earns little or loses money. A high price earns well but rarely wins. Somewhere in between, expected profit peaks. That's the price to start the discussion from.
The profit if won isn't a fixed number either. Your costs are uncertain, so at any price there's a chance the project costs more than you get paid. That's the downside risk: the probability of a loss if you win. A sound price looks at both: the expected profit, and how likely it is that winning hurts.
Worked example: the Kestrow Link tunnel
Illustrative case. The project, client and competitors are fictional; the figures come from our Bid Price Optimizer sample report.
A contractor bids on a 42-month design and build lump sum contract for a bored tunnel, awarded on lowest price. The reference estimate, without risk, is EUR 267.0M. A Monte Carlo simulation of the cost lines and 15 discrete risks gives an expected cost of EUR 282.0M and a P80 cost of EUR 291.3M. The break-even price is EUR 289.3M. Bid cost is EUR 1.20M.
Five named competitors are expected, each with its own chance of taking part and its own price range. Including our contractor, that's 5.0 expected bidders, so a neutral win chance would be about 20%. The bid board has set three rules: a margin if won of at least 3.0%, a chance of a loss if won of at most 25%, and a win chance of at least 10%.
| Strategy | Price | P(win) | Expected profit | Margin if won | P(loss if won) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recommended | EUR 301.9M | 30.0% | EUR 2.49M | 4.1% | 14.3% |
| Defensive (target margin) | EUR 308.2M | 16.9% | EUR 1.92M | 6.0% | 6.2% |
| Aggressive (lowest within the rules) | EUR 299.1M | 36.9% | EUR 2.33M | 3.2% | 19.4% |
| Break-even | EUR 289.3M | 62.3% | EUR −1.20M | 0.0% | 47.5% |
Three things stand out:
- The target margin isn't the best price. Pricing for the full 6.0% margin nearly halves the chance of winning, and expected profit drops from EUR 2.49M to EUR 1.92M.
- Cheaper isn't safer. The aggressive price wins more often, but the chance of a loss if won climbs to 19.4% and expected profit is lower.
- The best price is a band, not a point. Between EUR 299.5M and EUR 303.1M, expected profit stays within 5% of the maximum. The board can choose within that band on strategy, such as order book or client relationship, without giving up real value.
At the recommended price, the win chance of 30% is above the neutral 20%, and all four decision rules are met. That's a defensible price, not a guaranteed win: the model is only as good as the cost ranges and competitor assumptions behind it.
Why the price with the highest win chance is rarely the best
Look at the last row. The break-even price wins 62.3% of the time, more than double the recommended price. But it earns nothing on average, so after bid cost the expected result is a loss of EUR 1.20M. And when you do win, the chance of losing money on the contract is 47.5%.
This is the winner's curse in tendering. In a lowest-price award, you tend to win precisely when your estimate is too low compared with the others. The lower you price, the more of your wins are the ones you'll regret. Maximizing win chance means buying work, and with cost risk on a lump sum contract, that bill comes due during delivery.
How bid history shapes the win-probability curve
The weakest input in most pricing models is the win probability. It depends on who bids and how they price, and you can't see that before the opening. You can, however, learn from the past:
- Log every bid. Record your price, your estimate, the outcome and, once published, the competitors' prices.
- Express competitor prices relative to your own estimate. A competitor who usually bids 2% to 8% above your estimate tells you more than an absolute number from a different project.
- Track how often each competitor shows up. Participation matters: a strong bidder who enters only 60% of the time lowers the pressure on price.
- Allow for a shared market mood. In a busy market everyone prices higher; in a quiet one, lower. In the Kestrow case, competitor prices move together through a market factor of 0.30.
- Compare your hit rate with the model. If you win far less often than predicted, your competitor ranges are too generous.
Each logged tender sharpens the curve for the next one. Even ten or fifteen bids give a much better basis than the bid team's memory.
Putting it together
- Use a fixed scorecard and knock-out questions to decide whether to bid at all.
- Price from a cost range, not one number, so you know the break-even price and the chance of a loss.
- Choose the price with the highest expected profit within the board's rules, and treat the near-optimal band as room for strategy.
- Log every bid and its outcome, and recalibrate the win curve with it.
None of this guarantees a win or a profit. It gives the bid board a clear view of the trade-off it's making, and a record of why.
Do it in Excel
The Bid Price Optimizer finds the bid price with the highest expected profit. It shows the win probability and the downside risk at every price, learns from your bid history, compares price strategies and writes a bid board memo. For how to read the cost confidence levels behind the break-even and contingency figures, see P50, P80 and P90 explained.